Wrestling with Mary Oliver on My Birthday

Pulling this from the archives without hurting my back.

A close-up of a sprinkle-covered slice of birthday cake with the candle letters "Ha" on top, sitting on a crumb-covered plate.

Permit me a wildly self-indulgent post. It is my birthday, and if a woman can’t spelunk into the gooey cavern of her own feelings on the anniversary of her arrival, then when can she?

“Tell me, what is it you plan to do with your one wild and precious life?”

I started this day as I do most days, forcing myself to wrestle with Mary Oliver.

For a while now, I’ve worked on carving out little havens for myself. Small sanctuaries filled with beautiful sounds and words and things to gaze upon and hold dear. I’ve tried to fill them with people, too. People who smile and cry, as needed. People who are an honor to stand with, or curl up next to, or double over in laughter with in the great messy queue of existence. And people who will, crucially, refrain from being grammar assholes over this entire paragraph.

And then I’ve worked on showing up in those havens, which is harder than you’d think. You’d think once you’ve carved out a space, you’d want to be in it, like a cat claiming a cardboard box. BUT NO. My instinct is to show up everywhere else first.

Those everywhere else spaces need people like me — people who are loud and unsoft in public. The spaces where people like me are asked to stand at the front and project their voices like a malfunctioning foghorn. The spaces where I need to show up (and shut up) so no one else has to be brave alone.

Those spaces can take your skin. Those spaces can be harsh and loud and brisk. I like none of those things.

Being unsoft in public isn’t easy. None of us is unsoft at all times. Even under-bridge trolls need an occasional snuggle and a nap. And I refuse to grow callouses. Callouses are for people who enjoy hiking or receiving constructive criticism, neither of which interests me.

But I go to the places I choose, and dwell among people I choose. Still, my unsoft places sometimes grow raw around the edges. Like a cheese that has been handled too enthusiastically at a village fête.

I want to be brave in this one wild and precious life, the kind of brave that requires ferocity and a willingness to occasionally be the cheese that stands alone. Sometimes I am the kind of brave that is also vulnerable. Different cheese, same position. But lots of people like cheese, I’ve learned. Somewhere out there are the people who love the exact cheese that is me.

I digress. I am also hungry for cheese.

Birthdays involve audits. Spiritual, emotional, sometimes literal, if you also store your things in creative locations and now want to use them to get your special birthday cookie at Crumbl. I use this day to ask myself: Am I who I want to be? Am I surrounded by marvelous, strong, brilliant, delightful people? Is the work mighty? Brave? Honest? (Is it occasionally funny, because bonus points for that.)

This past year has been…well, let’s say it has tested us all in ways that rattle our molars and make us long to burrow under blankets and just stay there for a good chunk of this wild and precious life.

But this is a new year. Every day can be a new year. This is why I wrestle with Mary Oliver and her profoundly, annoyingly inspirational poem.

I’m grateful for my people and our co-carved spaces, and the fact that I have the energy to carve them, and also for the baffling email from my insurance agency wishing me a happy birthday as if we’ve been through something together.

And I’m grateful for the privilege of being invited into some of your spaces.

Because at the end of the day, I hope to ease into another part of that poem: “Tell me, what else should I have done?” and know the answer is

“Nothing more.”

Thank goodness.

Thank goodness.

What I Read October 2026

OH, HERE WE GO. SHE’S DIFFICULT.

Graphic with a smoky black background and red-orange lettering reading “What I Read October 2026” and “Oh, Here We Go. She’s Difficult.” Below are the covers of four books by Hannah Arendt, Rebecca Solnit, Jacqueline Harpman, and Karen Karbo.

There are many ways to be a difficult woman. You can be too loud, too quiet, too emotional, too detached, too interested in the proceedings, or insufficiently grateful to have been invited to the proceedings in the first place. You can talk too much (bad), or too little, (suspicious). You can ask a question (too much!). You can ask a FOLLOW-UP question (an act of war). You can point out that the question itself is idiotic, (have your affairs in order before attempting this one).

And then it’s all OH, HERE WE GO. SHE’S DIFFICULT. LET’S GET RID OF THIS BROAD.

Getting rid of difficult women is a time-honored tradition of our species. We’ve tried drowning, burning, confinement, bogs, marriage, hysteria diagnoses, and ostracism. These days we also have text groups and PTAs, all of which save considerably on firewood.

We call her shrill. We call her angry. We call her difficult. A remarkably versatile little word, “difficult.” You don’t even have to specify what the woman has done. Everyone will automatically nod and scoot their chairs a little further away out of a vague sense of discomfort.

We could actually use more difficult people. Put them on every committee, board, corporate retreat, strategic planning session, HOA, task force, listening session, leadership summit, or anything that begins with an unironic icebreaker. Give her a Difficult Person Slide Whistle™ and the authority to blow it whenever somebody says something stupid. No appeals process.

I’ve got thoughts, clearly. Let me tell you, this was a heck of a month to go on a dangerous women reading kick.

These were, without question, the most Octobery reads I’ve had in a while. Spooky, yet not a zombie in the bunch, although plenty of ideas that should have died centuries ago keep digging themselves out of the ground. You can put away the plastic skeletons, eat the discount candy, and take down the fake cobwebs, but the oppression, lies, institutional rot, hatred, and hierarchies? Still here, asking if the cranberry sauce at Thanksgiving is homemade or from a can.

A cheery little assortment of books! Just the thing to curl up with while civilization does whatever it is doing to increase my ice cream consumption and under-blanket marathon sessions.

I waffled over my favorite this month. The Mother of All Questions or I Who Have Never Known Men? One is non-fiction, one is fiction, both are excellent, and I’m not industrious enough to write two full reviews. Read either or both books with my blessing.

Anyway, this month’s victims of my enthusiasm is…

The Mother of All Questions by Rebecca Solnit

Solnit’s The Mother of All Questions tackles feminism, violence, silence, masculinity, and other sundry boxes into which we insist on stuffing women. It opens with Solnit recalling a lecture about Virginia Woolf during which audience members wanted to know whether Woolf had children (and whether she should have.) Here’s a woman with a formidable intellectual reputation whose writing changed the world, and somebody in this lecture thought, “You know what we haven’t covered in this academic discussion of Virginia Woolf? HER UTERUS.”

Solnit waxes brilliant on silencing, which doesn’t always involve telling someone to shut up. We’ve figured out how to make speaking so unpleasant that eventually a woman decides it’s not worth the trouble, and we say that it was her choice to stop. Punish women for speaking and then blame them for their silence. Brilliant and monstrous.

I loved this funny, rigorous book. Solnit has a gift for exposing the rot behind things we regard as perfectly normal.

Read this if you want analysis of oppressive systems that silence a lot of us and yet you want hope that we can unmake what we have made.


Honorable Mentions:

I Who Have Never Known Men by Jacqueline Harpman

Forty women locked in an underground bunker, watched, regulated, and denied everything that might make life worth living, including physical affection and any explanation of why they’re there. Thirty-nine remember a life before imprisonment. The fortieth, our narrator and the youngest in the group, remembers nothing. She has no idea what she’s missing, which is both a terrible thing and in a few horrific instances, a survival advantage.

Eventually the women escape, but outside the bunker the world is bleak and also without explanation, basic amenities, or hope. If Plato’s prisoners leave their cave and discover a larger reality, Harpman’s women leave theirs and discover that the larger reality is more of the same.

The narrator has never known men. She has never known most of the things by which we understand ourselves. We learn throughout the book what makes her human.

Harpman refuses to explain much, which is frustrating, and yet somehow that frustration is part of what makes the book extraordinary. It’s spare, unsettling, occasionally horrifying, and profoundly sad. This one will haunt me for a long time.

Read it if you’re interested in existential literature but don’t want to spend the weekend curled up with Kierkegaard.

In Praise of Difficult Women by Karen Karbo

I like to think I’m a difficult woman, although I also know there’s a fine line between challenging the status quo and being a general pain in the ass. (But if you set your mind to it, you can do both!) Karbo gives us twenty-nine women who were uninterested in making themselves more palatable and who had the audacity to act on their opinions, ambitions, and appetites. She writes that “sometimes the cost of being fully human is upsetting people.” AMEN. I skipped the Rowling chapter and considered DNFing because the profiles felt a little glossy, but I was stuck in a car for three hours with nothing else to read. So onward! The women were fascinating. I wanted more of their contradictions and insubordination. I wanted more excavation, less of an introduction to being difficult. Still, better than three hours of scrolling my phone.

Read if you want a solid introduction to some fantastically difficult women. Feel free to skip the Rowling chapter. Better yet, share this book with a young person who could use a launchpad for being difficult.

On Lying and Politics by Hannah Arendt

A slim volume of two essays about political deception, organized lying, and the crises they create. Arendt uses the word “defactualization” to describe what happens when facts lose their authority and those in power exploit the resulting confusion. What an excellent word! What a perfectly awful thing to need an excellent word for! Although Arendt wrote these essays more than fifty years ago, I kept wanting to check the publication date. Surely someone had slipped a few pages in the last year or so?. Despite what you may have heard, Arendt isn’t impossible to read, but she is impossible to skim. That’s a good thing. Slow down and attend. (Bonus points to David Bromwich and his introduction which bridges the decades, though, again, that distance is shorter than you might wish)

Read if you’d like to understand how we got here, although you may not particularly enjoy recognizing the scenery.


And there be the October books. Read anything good lately?

OH, HERE WE GO. SHE’S DIFFICULT.

Graphic with a smoky black background and red-orange lettering reading “What I Read October 2026” and “Oh, Here We Go. She’s Difficult.” Below are the covers of four books by Hannah Arendt, Rebecca Solnit, Jacqueline Harpman, and Karen Karbo.

There are many ways to be a difficult woman. You can be too loud, too quiet, too emotional, too detached, too interested in the proceedings, or insufficiently grateful to have been invited to the proceedings in the first place. You can talk too much (bad), or too little, (suspicious). You can ask a question (too much!). You can ask a FOLLOW-UP question (an act of war). You can point out that the question itself is idiotic, (have your affairs in order before attempting this one).

And then it’s all OH, HERE WE GO. SHE’S DIFFICULT. LET’S GET RID OF THIS BROAD.

Getting rid of difficult women is a time-honored tradition of our species. We’ve tried drowning, burning, confinement, bogs, marriage, hysteria diagnoses, and ostracism. These days we also have text groups and PTAs, all of which save considerably on firewood.

We call her shrill. We call her angry. We call her difficult. A remarkably versatile little word, “difficult.” You don’t even have to specify what the woman has done. Everyone will automatically nod and scoot their chairs a little further away out of a vague sense of discomfort.

We could actually use more difficult people. Put them on every committee, board, corporate retreat, strategic planning session, HOA, task force, listening session, leadership summit, or anything that begins with an unironic icebreaker. Give her a Difficult Person Slide Whistle™ and the authority to blow it whenever somebody says something stupid. No appeals process.

I’ve got thoughts, clearly. Let me tell you, this was a heck of a month to go on a dangerous women reading kick.

These were, without question, the most Octobery reads I’ve had in a while. Spooky, yet not a zombie in the bunch, although plenty of ideas that should have died centuries ago keep digging themselves out of the ground. You can put away the plastic skeletons, eat the discount candy, and take down the fake cobwebs, but the oppression, lies, institutional rot, hatred, and hierarchies? Still here, asking if the cranberry sauce at Thanksgiving is homemade or from a can.

A cheery little assortment of books! Just the thing to curl up with while civilization does whatever it is doing to increase my ice cream consumption and under-blanket marathon sessions.

I waffled over my favorite this month. The Mother of All Questions or I Who Have Never Known Men? One is non-fiction, one is fiction, both are excellent, and I’m not industrious enough to write two full reviews. Read either or both books with my blessing.

Anyway, this month’s victims of my enthusiasm is…

The Mother of All Questions by Rebecca Solnit

Solnit’s The Mother of All Questions tackles feminism, violence, silence, masculinity, and other sundry boxes into which we insist on stuffing women. It opens with Solnit recalling a lecture about Virginia Woolf during which audience members wanted to know whether Woolf had children (and whether she should have.) Here’s a woman with a formidable intellectual reputation whose writing changed the world, and somebody in this lecture thought, “You know what we haven’t covered in this academic discussion of Virginia Woolf? HER UTERUS.”

Solnit waxes brilliant on silencing, which doesn’t always involve telling someone to shut up. We’ve figured out how to make speaking so unpleasant that eventually a woman decides it’s not worth the trouble, and we say that it was her choice to stop. Punish women for speaking and then blame them for their silence. Brilliant and monstrous.

I loved this funny, rigorous book. Solnit has a gift for exposing the rot behind things we regard as perfectly normal.

Read this if you want analysis of oppressive systems that silence a lot of us and yet you want hope that we can unmake what we have made.


Honorable Mentions:

I Who Have Never Known Men by Jacqueline Harpman

Forty women locked in an underground bunker, watched, regulated, and denied everything that might make life worth living, including physical affection and any explanation of why they’re there. Thirty-nine remember a life before imprisonment. The fortieth, our narrator and the youngest in the group, remembers nothing. She has no idea what she’s missing, which is both a terrible thing and in a few horrific instances, a survival advantage.

Eventually the women escape, but outside the bunker the world is bleak and also without explanation, basic amenities, or hope. If Plato’s prisoners leave their cave and discover a larger reality, Harpman’s women leave theirs and discover that the larger reality is more of the same.

The narrator has never known men. She has never known most of the things by which we understand ourselves. We learn throughout the book what makes her human.

Harpman refuses to explain much, which is frustrating, and yet somehow that frustration is part of what makes the book extraordinary. It’s spare, unsettling, occasionally horrifying, and profoundly sad. This one will haunt me for a long time.

Read it if you’re interested in existential literature but don’t want to spend the weekend curled up with Kierkegaard.

In Praise of Difficult Women by Karen Karbo

I like to think I’m a difficult woman, although I also know there’s a fine line between challenging the status quo and being a general pain in the ass. (But if you set your mind to it, you can do both!) Karbo gives us twenty-nine women who were uninterested in making themselves more palatable and who had the audacity to act on their opinions, ambitions, and appetites. She writes that “sometimes the cost of being fully human is upsetting people.” AMEN. I skipped the Rowling chapter and considered DNFing because the profiles felt a little glossy, but I was stuck in a car for three hours with nothing else to read. So onward! The women were fascinating. I wanted more of their contradictions and insubordination. I wanted more excavation, less of an introduction to being difficult. Still, better than three hours of scrolling my phone.

Read if you want a solid introduction to some fantastically difficult women. Feel free to skip the Rowling chapter. Better yet, share this book with a young person who could use a launchpad for being difficult.

On Lying and Politics by Hannah Arendt

A slim volume of two essays about political deception, organized lying, and the crises they create. Arendt uses the word “defactualization” to describe what happens when facts lose their authority and those in power exploit the resulting confusion. What an excellent word! What a perfectly awful thing to need an excellent word for! Although Arendt wrote these essays more than fifty years ago, I kept wanting to check the publication date. Surely someone had slipped a few pages in the last year or so?. Despite what you may have heard, Arendt isn’t impossible to read, but she is impossible to skim. That’s a good thing. Slow down and attend. (Bonus points to David Bromwich and his introduction which bridges the decades, though, again, that distance is shorter than you might wish)

Read if you’d like to understand how we got here, although you may not particularly enjoy recognizing the scenery.


And there be the October books. Read anything good lately?

A Bestiary of Modern Horseshit

Aged parchment background with ornate, dark red lettering reading "A Bestiary of Modern Horseshit," with "Jackie Pick" in smaller text beneath.

Once upon a time, a woman went online shopping for the end of the world.

Perhaps she should have scrolled for armor, or a sword hammered from the bones of a dead god, or a palette of freeze-dried beef stroganoff.

She shopped for pants. Velour pants with a 28” inseam because she was willing to confront the forces of darkness but not with muddy cuffs. Maybe a matching sweatshirt. A complete velour tracksuit.

She sat in a parking lot, awaiting the return of her child from one of the many activities required of modern children. The woman was exhausted. She was weepy, but not beautifully so. Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young’s So Far played.

She’d been scrolling. The scrolling disgorged the usual monsters as well as new species. Brotherhoods, Two-headed Chieftain Beasties, Keepers of Things, Couriers, and Tribunals, all bowing to His Most Blameless Majesty, while casting truth into the moat. Pactum Virorum.

(There were lesser demons, of course, that wouldn’t devour the kingdom but merely infest every corner of it. For example, those who insist on calling sandwiches “handhelds.”)

The woman had slain none of these monsters, though not for lack of trying.

She had, however, become extremely tired of them, so she looked at velour tracksuits. Then her algorithm offered up fleece capes. Fleece capes possess neither the grandeur of a cloak nor the practical advantages of withstanding a direct assault by a collapsing institution, but she could be a little comfortable. And yet, and yet, comfort is not consolation, and neither one is repair.

The woman considered this and considered her life and her algorithm. She glanced up, trying to catch a glimpse of her child at practice or rehearsal or a meet or a match or in conversation. Safe, for now. She considered this as well.

Perhaps the woman could become a witch, she thought. Not one of the beautiful witches, with their flowing black hair and rings of moonstone. A different sort. A Richard Simmons witch, if you will, but one who had all but abandoned the cardio.

She would stand before the monsters and say their true names. LIAR. COWARD. FRAUD. SANDWICH.

The woman sat in her car, waiting for her daughter, listening to music and welling up (again! still!) from loving a world determined to destroy its own better qualities. Although she was not languishing, she was tired of the monsters devouring everything and everyone, then demanding gratitude for doing so.

And so the Velour Tracksuit Witch of the Fleece Cape, wearing neither cape nor velour tracksuit, considered the many ways the kingdom described its troubles in elaborate think-pieces bewailing the decline of civility (and by all means, please ignore the dragon in the mead hall). Elegant chronicles all.

The woman had lately become inclined toward a less elegant description. Everything Is Horseshit.

Yet the Witch Woman Who Was Not a Witch, sitting in a parking lot, listening to Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young, waiting for her daughter, contemplating a fleece cape, conceded that every proper account of monsters must also acknowledge the possibility of something good surviving.

She made a comprehensive list That Which is Not Horseshit:

  1. Reese’s Peanut Butter Pumpkins